As one of the local papers here headlined it, “Veep debate pits hockey moms against rail riders.”
Let's see how she does....
********************
Gwen Ifill laid down the rules and conditions of the debate before introducing the candidates.
The first question went to Senator Biden, asking him about the bailout and whether it was a good or bad idea.
His response was predictable: it's all the Republicans fault, and particularly President Bush.
Palin's response: ask the parents at a kids soccer game what they think. You'll get a more accurate response about the economy, the stock market, and the bank meltdowns than you'll get from Congress or the talking heads.
Both said partisanship should be set aside, but the question is who would better be able to deal with the situation.
********************
The next question dealt with the sub-prime lending meltdown, and who was a fault: the predatory lenders or the risk-taking borrowers?
Palin responded: “Darn right it was the predatory lenders who tried to talk Americans into thinking it was smart to buy a $300,000 house when they could only afford a $100,000 house. There was greed and corruption on Wall Street.” She played the Joe Sixpack/hockey mom card, too, sayign we should be smart and not live outside our means.
Biden: “Barack warned about sub-prime loans, and McCain promoted them.” Really? Yet there's plenty of video showing McCain speaking out against such practices and warning that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were out of control.
Palin's rebuttal: Obama had almost 100 chances to help cut taxes on the middle class, but didn't.
Biden: She didn't say anything about deregulation!
Palin: So what. I'm speaking to the American people. I know about cutting taxes and getting it back to the people.
********************
About taxes:
Biden: Taxes are about fairness. (Excuse me? Since when are taxes about fairness? Most of the middle class doesn't pay any taxes, so how can you cut them?)
Plain: Paying higher taxes is patriotic? Better that government get out of the way and let everyone keep more of their money. Government is more often the problem and not the solution. Redistribution of wealth is not the answer.
Biden: It's about fairness! No tax cuts for businesses. More taxes on the wealthy.
********************
Health care: I'm not sure. Biden's response jumped all over the place. He threw a lot of numbers around and I didn't record it.
********************
Energy:
Palin: Unlike Obama, I took on oil companies, broke up a monopoly and got oil companies to pay taxes they were trying to get out of. She isn't popular with oil company CEO's.
Biden: Oil companies got $4 billion in tax breaks. They make billions, which is obscene.
Palin: Obama voted for those tax breaks. We need to do everything we can to ensure our energy supplies. But East Coast politicians won't let us tap our own resources, energy we have in abundance.
********************
Climate change:
Palin: I do not attribute every change in the climate to man's activities, much of it is part of a natural cycle. But we still need to deal with it. Our energy policies have some effect on that, exporting our pollution to other countires.
Biden: Climate change is clearly totally man made. We should be investing money in alternative energy technologies, not drilling. Ten years until first well produces a drop of oil.
Palin: We want an 'all of the above' approach to energy independence.
Biden: McCain has voted against alternative energy technologies for 20 years.
********************
Gay rights:
Biden: I believe there should be no restrictions for gay couples when it comes to rights and privileges.
Palin: I have done what others only talk about. But I don't support gay marriage.
Biden: Neither do I.
********************
Iran/Iraq:
Palin: We cannot withdraw from Iraq prematurely, but we have been slowly dropping troop levels to below surge levels. Obama voted against the surge. He wanted a non-negotiable withdrawal timetable.
Biden: McCain voted against troop funding because of the timetable.
Palin: The 16 month withdrawal was nothing more than a white flag of surrender.
Biden: McCain voted against troop funding because of the timetable. (Yes, it's a repeat, but that's what he said, three times.) McCain has been wrong about Iraq (He repeated this four times).
********************
Bigger threat – nuclear Iran or an unstable Pakistan?
Biden: Pakistan already has nuclear weapons. Iran getting them would be very destablizing. McCain says center of war against terror is Iraq, but it's in Pakistan. Attack on US won't come from Iraq. 7000 madrassas built in Pakistan. Instead should be building schools. We should go after bin Laden no matter where he's hiding.
Palin: General Petraeus and the leader of al Qaeda both agree it was the center. A nuclear Iran is far too do dangerous and unstable. Meeting with Ahmahdinejad or Kim Jong Il without conditions is not a smart thing. Israel is in jeopardy, and that can't be ignored, particularly when Iran has stated they will see it destroyed.
Biden: We should meet with our enemies! Our allies are on the same page. Former Secretaries of State agree. John McCain won't even meet with Spain, a NATO ally. (Biden keeps trying to tie McCain to Bush, implying McCain is no different than Bush.)
Palin: How is it that McCain, who has gone against Bush on many levels, is no different than Bush?
********************
Use of nuclear weapons:
Palin: Rogue nations should not have such weapons. We should do what we can to deny them that type of weapon.
Biden: Afghanistan: Surge will not work in Afghanistan. We haven't spent nearly enough in Afghanistan as we have in Iraq. Nuclear: McCain voted against every anti-nuclear strategy.
********************
Interventionism:
Biden: Supported interventionism in Bosnia, thought going into Iraq a mistake but supported President, should go into Darfur to prevent genocide.
Palin: I guess I am a Washington outsider because I don't understand how you can vote for war before you voted against it. If you voted for it, explain why you did.
Biden: There is a line that must be drawn to prevent genocide. Iraq was wrong.
Palin: I disagree in regards to Iraq being wrong, but the handling of it was wrong.
********************
If had to take over presidency:
Biden: God forbid it should come to that, but I would carry out Obama's policies, including replacement of the Bush Doctrine. This is the most important election since 1932!!
Palin: Heaven forbid, indeed! What do you expect from a team of mavericks? I would continue to do his work, putting government back on the side of the people, and get rid of corruption in Washington and Wall Street. We need to bring a bit of reality from Wasilla's Main Street brought to Washington DC so that people there can understand how the average working class family is viewing bureaucracy and the federal government and Congress and the inaction in Congress. Get out of our way!
********************
At this point I was falling farther behind and couldn't keep up, so I didn't try.
My impression? I think Palin did well. As one of her Democratic opponents in Alaska warned Joe Biden, “She's in her element in debates, so do not underestimate her. She'll hand you your head and you'll wonder what happened.” She came across as the average American woman, the neighbor everyone likes, the type you want to invite over for a cookout.
Biden, on the other hand, came across as the 30+ year career politician he is. He was slick. He used many of the Washington buzz words and phrases we've all heard throughout darn near every presidential campaign. He was sincere, lawyerly, senatorial, even at times I believed he was wrong.
My call: Palin took this one, but she did not overwhelm Biden. But I think she proved she was “one of us” and not a Washington insider. I think we need someone from outside the Washington power elite to come to town, point out the things that seem stupid by saying, “Whoa! Look at that!s Isn't that silly?”
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are welcome. However personal attacks, legally actionable accusations,or threats made to post authors or those commenting upon posts will get those committing such acts banned from commenting.